IHSA Files Comment Opposing Proposed Head Start Rule

IHSA Comment on the Proposed Rule "Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs"

Docket ID: ACF-2026-0595 | RIN: 0970-AD30 | Federal Register: 91 Fed. Reg. 51248 (August 7, 2026)

Download the full comment (PDF) Download the executive summary (PDF)

The Illinois Head Start Association submitted this comment to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services through regulations.gov. The executive summary is below. Both the executive summary and the full comment are available as PDFs. You can also view the docket on regulations.gov.

Who we represent

Executive Summary

Illinois Head Start Association
Comments on the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking: Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs
RIN: 0970-AD30 | Docket ID: ACF-2026-0595

The Illinois Head Start Association (IHSA) strongly opposes the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services' Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM), Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs, published August 7, 2026. The proposed rule would eliminate approximately 90 percent of the existing Head Start Program Performance Standards (HSPPS), fundamentally altering the framework that has guided the delivery of high-quality, comprehensive Head Start and Early Head Start services for decades. Despite the Administration's stated goals of increasing flexibility, reducing administrative burden, and serving more children, IHSA believes the proposed changes would increase costs and operational burdens, weaken accountability, destabilize the workforce, reduce essential services, and place the future of Head Start programs and the children and families they serve at risk. IHSA urges the Department to withdraw the proposed rule in its entirety.

IHSA supports 51 federally recognized Head Start and Early Head Start agencies and 84 delegate agencies operating 513 program sites throughout Illinois. Our members serve more than 28,000 children and their families across all 102 Illinois counties, from urban centers to rural communities. These programs provide critical services to children with disabilities, children experiencing homelessness, children in foster care, dual language learners, pregnant women, infants, toddlers, and families facing significant economic and personal challenges. To inform these comments, IHSA conducted seven focus group sessions with administrators, staff, parents, and community partners, along with 20 onsite meetings with frontline staff. Their experiences consistently demonstrate that the proposed rule would undermine the comprehensive, community-driven model that makes Head Start effective.

The proposed rule would increase administrative burden and threaten program stability. The current HSPPS serve as the operational guidebook for Head Start agencies, translating the Head Start Act into clear, consistent, and measurable requirements. Eliminating these standards would force programs to interpret broad statutory provisions, develop new policies and procedures, revise established community partnerships, and navigate uncertainty about federal expectations. At the same time, the proposed reduction of the administrative cost cap from 15 percent to 5 percent would place extraordinary pressure on program infrastructure. In Illinois, no Head Start or Early Head Start program currently operates at or below the proposed 5 percent threshold. Programs anticipate staff reductions, increased workloads, diminished fiscal and administrative capacity, and potential program closures. These changes would not simply shift funding toward direct services; they could undermine the systems necessary to deliver and sustain those services.

The proposed rule would destabilize the workforce and diminish the quality of early childhood education. Eliminating standards related to staff qualifications, professional development, coaching, wellness, classroom ratios, and group sizes would increase demands on an already strained workforce. Larger classrooms, fewer teachers and home visitors, reduced support for children with disabilities and challenging behaviors, and diminished access to mental health consultation would compromise the relationships and individualized attention essential to children's development. The proposed English-only instruction requirement is particularly concerning in Illinois, where just over 50 percent of enrolled Head Start and Early Head Start children are dual language learners. This requirement conflicts with the Head Start Act's emphasis on supporting children's development in their primary language while they acquire English, and could force programs to retrain or lose qualified bilingual educators, disrupt children's learning, and create additional compliance challenges.

The proposed rule would weaken protections for children and reduce access to essential comprehensive services. The HSPPS establish expectations for education, health, nutrition, mental health, disability services, family engagement, home visiting, and child safety. Removing these requirements would leave programs with less guidance and fewer assurances that children and families will receive the services they need. IHSA is particularly concerned about the consequences for children with disabilities, families experiencing homelessness, children in foster care, dual language learners, pregnant women, infants and toddlers, and families navigating domestic violence, substance use, housing instability, and other crises. Additional eligibility documentation requirements could prevent otherwise eligible children from enrolling, while the elimination of community assessment and recruitment standards could make it more difficult for programs to identify and prioritize children with the greatest needs. These changes risk widening disparities rather than expanding meaningful access to high-quality early childhood services.

The proposed rule would weaken parental partnership, consistency, and accountability. Meaningful family engagement and shared governance are defining features of Head Start. The proposed changes would diminish established opportunities for parents to participate in program decisions, exercise leadership through Policy Councils and parent committees, and partner with staff to support their children's development and their families' goals. At the same time, eliminating clear program standards while retaining broad federal monitoring and enforcement authority would create uncertainty about compliance, increase the potential for inconsistent decisions, and leave agencies less able to anticipate or prevent findings during federal reviews. The resulting variability would undermine the consistent, high-quality experience families expect from Head Start, regardless of where they live or which program they attend.

The proposed rule's consequences extend beyond individual programs. Illinois Head Start agencies are essential community partners, employers, and connectors to health care, social services, early intervention, and other resources. Reducing their capacity would affect local service networks, workforce stability, and the broader communities that depend on these partnerships. The loss of clear national standards would also weaken a longstanding model of comprehensive early childhood education that has informed state preschool systems and other early childhood initiatives.

Head Start's success rests on its commitment to the whole child, the whole family, and the community. Flexibility should enable programs to respond to local needs while maintaining the safeguards that ensure quality, safety, inclusion, and accountability. Eliminating the vast majority of the HSPPS without a clear, workable framework to replace them would not reduce burden or strengthen Head Start. It would create uncertainty, increase operational challenges, and diminish the services that children and families rely on.

For these reasons, the Illinois Head Start Association respectfully urges the Department of Health and Human Services to withdraw the NPRM in its entirety and preserve the Head Start Program Performance Standards as the foundation for high-quality, comprehensive, and accountable Head Start and Early Head Start services. Illinois children and families deserve a program that expands opportunity without sacrificing quality, protects those with the greatest needs, supports the professionals who serve them, and ensures that every child has the opportunity to thrive.

Download the full comment (PDF) Download the executive summary (PDF)